Treasury Committee questions mortgage providers
Over in parliament, MPs on the Treasury Committee are starting to question mortgage providers on rising rates, house prices and forbearance.
It’s a timely hearing, given average two-year fixed mortgage rates have just hit a 15-year high of 6.66%.
Here’s what to expect, from the committee:
The cross-party Committee of MPs will examine the current state of the mortgage market, including levels of mortgage stress, arrears and forbearance, and the outlook for the market in light of higher interest rates.
The Committee will question mortgage providers on consumer behaviour following recent rate rises, the impact on house prices and the wider housing market, and mortgage affordability and availability.
Government support schemes and the recently agreed ‘mortgage charter’ are also likely to be discussed, as are buy-to-let mortgages and the rental market, and the take-up of long-term fixed rate deals.
Here’s the panel:
-
Andrew Asaam, Homes Director, Lloyds Banking Group
-
Bradley Fordham, Mortgage Director, Santander UK
-
Charlotte Harrison, Interim CEO (Home Financing), Skipton Building Society
-
Henry Jordan, Home Commercial Director, Nationwide
-
Nigel Terrington, Chief Executive, Paragon Banking Group
Key events
Rising mortgage rates could reach ‘tipping point’, MPs hear
MPs on the Treasury committee have also been warned that mortgage rates could rise to a ‘tipping point’.
According to Henry Jordan, home commercial director at Nationwide, that could be between 6.25% and 6.5% for customers remortgaging their home loans.
We covered earlier that Jordan had explained that borrowers face an average increase of £235 per month as they move off existing fixed rate deals (at, say, 2.25%) onto new ones at around 5.5%.
Jordan told MPs that a customer who extends the term of their mortgage could cut the monthly increase to £134.
If they also move to an interest-only product, then they could move to a lower payment than they’re paying currently.
That remains true, Jordon says, until average remortgaging rates reach between 6.25% to 6.5%.
That might be a tipping point at which options such as interest only won’t be sufficient to offset the increase in payments that customer will see.
We flagged earlier that average two-year mortgage rates are now 6.66%, but a customer remortgaging with their lender will typically get a lower rate than that.
Bank of England may need to keep rates higher for longer, IMF says
Newsflash: The Bank of England may need to keep interest rates high for an extended period if inflation pressures persist, the International Monetary Fund’s directors have warned.
In a review of the UK economy, the IMF warns that the country faces a challenging economic outlook, despite being expected to avoid a recession.
The IMF warns that the UK’s long-run prosperity hinges on “ambitious reforms”.
And in a stern assessment of Britain’s economic progress, the Fund says that the UK, once a “strong performer”, has now lost economic momentum.
It explains:
Prior to the 2008 global financial crisis, the UK had been a strong performer among the Group of Seven countries. But this momentum was lost in the middle of the last decade. By 2022, real business investment was still slightly lower than in 2016 — in contrast to the 14 percent increase among other G7 economies.
Labor supply, which has just reached its pre-pandemic level, has also been weaker than peers. As in other advanced economies, productivity growth has been sluggish, reflecting a slower pace of innovation and technological diffusion.
The IMF says it is critical to improve UK health outcomes, due to the long-term sickness that has driven the post-pandemic spike in inactivity.
And they say investor confidence would be boosted by a stable, long-term strategy to promote business investment – which could include a “permanent set of tax incentives that could potentially apply to investments other than plant and machinery”.
Chancellor Jeremy Hunt announced a temporary ‘full expensing’ tax break in March’s budget.
And, as it concludes its annual Article IV consultation with the UK, the IMF welcomed last month’s hike in interest rates to 5% – and warned that more may be needed.
The fund says:
Directors welcomed the Bank of England’s (BoE) policy response to arrest inflation pressures, including the 50 bps policy rate increase on June 22.
Given risks and uncertainty about the outlook and inflation persistence, Directors concurred that a continuous review of the pace and magnitude of monetary tightening is warranted. Should inflationary pressures show signs of further persistence, the policy rate may have to be raised further and would need to remain higher for longer to durably lower inflation and keep inflation expectations anchored.
Back at the Treasury Committee:
Q: Are first-time buyers still trying to enter the housing market?
Andrew Asaam, homes director at Lloyds Banking Group, says the overall housing market is smaller this year than in 2021 and 2022, when the pandemic race-for-space was fuelling demand, as was the stamp duty holiday.
Its more similar to 2019, he says. Within that, the FTB market is smaller too.
People are either putting down a larger deposit, or buying a smaller property because affordability is tighter.
We won’t lent people as much now, with rates where they are, as we would historically.
Q: Are you seeing an impact on house prices?
Asaam points to the monthly house price index produced by its Halifax arm, which he says showed “a moderation in house prices” [the biggest fall in 12 years in June], while Lloyds forecast a 5% drop this year in its results.
Helena Horton
Thames Water CEO Cathryn Ross then told the London Assembly Environment Committee that “progressive charging” for water bills would mean customers with the means to do so could pay more.
Ross expained, during this morning’s hearing:
“If we found a more progressive way of charging we would unlock the ability to charge those who can pay more”.
Defending privatisation, Ross compared it to mortgaging a home:
“We use finance to smooth the cost of those projects over a big period. We don’t get that money for free, when investors do give us that money they expect a return. They should get a reasonable level of return rather than an egregious level of return.
If our investors get the sort of return Ofwat says is fair, that’s absolutely fine with them. That would mean we would pay some dividends if we were getting that level of return.
We are not a profitable company. The annual results that we put out on Monday – we are making a loss of £30m after tax. This will be the sixth year they have not taken a dividend and they are putting a significant amount of money into the company. We are not at the position at the moment of having any profit to give back to shareholders.
“When water companies were privatised they were privatised with a clean balance sheet – no debt. One of the reasons they were privatised is it was known there was a huge amount of investment that was needed. You can pay for that investment as you go so the cost of all that goes on the customer bill today. Or you can spread the cost.
One of the reasons why the water companies were privatised in the way that they were was so the cost could be smoothed over time. We have taken a lot of debt, our total debt at the moment is £14bn. But you have to remember that our assets are worth £19bn. If we are taking on more debt to make our assets worth more it is like borrowing more to do an extension on your mortgaged house – it increases the value of your house.”
On whether nationalisation is feasible she said “I don’t really have a view” and said it was a matter for “government manifestos in the context of an election”.
Thames Water CEO quizzed over leakage failings
Helena Horton
The interim CEO of Thames Water is being grilled right now by the London Assembly Environment Committee.
Cathryn Ross took over the unenviable role of running the beleagured water company after the abrupt departure of former CEO Sarah Bentley.
She told the committee that we take water for granted in this country, and the government’s Plan for Water is not ambitious enough.
She said:
“I don’t think at the moment the Plan for Water goes far enough. It’s a useful step forward but doesn’t go far enough. Yes there is more we need to do but we actually need to change our national conversation about water. We need to understand for example that London has the same rainfall as Jerusalem and we aren’t living in a wet country where we can take water for granted.”
Ross was also grilled on Thames Water’s woeful record on leaks by Environment Committee Chairwoman Leonie Cooper, who said:
“It’s an unthinkable quantity. How can we persuade people to use less water if Thames Water is losing 602m litres a day?”
The CEO added:
“You are quite right, I accept we are not where we need to be on leakage. I also completely understand, and we were seeing this last year, that when we were asking customers to use water wisely, this quite rightly was undermined by customers saying well we are doing our bit, why aren’t you doing your bit.”
But added she has “increased the number of [leak fixing] gangs out there” and Thames Water is “literally fixing a leak every seven and a half minutes, that hasn’t happened before”.
She added that a third of leaks are from holes in customers’ pipes rather than in Thames water’s pipes.
Bradley Fordham, mortgage director at Santander UK, says there are signs that some customers are looking to cancel subscriptions, as they focus their financial resources in the cost-of-living squeeze.
But there isn’t any particular sign of deterioration among unsecured borrowers, Fordham tells the Treasury committee.
Sunak: absolutely determined to stick to course on inflation
Over in Vilnius, prime minister Rishi Sunak has admitted inflation is “proving to be more persistent than people thought”.
Speaking to broadcasters as he travels to the NATO leaders summit, the Prime Minister acknowledged “things are difficult” for families across the country amid a rise in interest rates. But he insists that his course of action isn’t “wrong”.
Sunak told reporters:
“I know things are difficult for many families across the country. The UK is not alone in experiencing a rise in interest rates… the crucial thing that we have to do is bring inflation down.
“That’s how we’re going to ease the burden for families. That’s how we’re going to stop the rise in interest rates. And that’s why my priority is to halve inflation.
“Of course, that is proving to be more persistent than people thought, but that doesn’t mean the course of action is wrong. We’ve got to stick to it.”
Q: What concerns do you have that people who extend their terms or move to interest-only loans are only deferring the pain, and will end up paying more overall?
Henry Jordan, home commercial director at Nationwide, suggests that customers may be able to reduce their terms in future years, if interest rates come down again.
Q: How many mortgage prisoners do you have?
Andrew Asaam says Lloyds has no mortgage prisoners – all its customers can get a ‘front book rate’.
Q: What else can banks do to prevent house repossessions?
Andrew Asaam, homes director at Lloyds Banking Group, says Lloyds have been phoning fixed-rate customers who are potentially high risk to offer them the chance to extend loan terms or lock in a deal now.
Customers on variable-rates are told if they could save by moving to another product.
And for customers in financial difficulties, there are a range of tools to help with loan forebearance and keep them in their homes, and “only use repossession as a last resort”.
Q: So, what’s the point of the mortgage charter if you’re already doing most of the options already? Has the chancellor added anything substantive?
Andrew Asaam, Lloyd’s homes director, says it provides clarity and consistency for customers.
And with inflation still high, it’s a helpful intervention “as things progress”, Asaam adds.
Q: 85% of the market are covered by this voluntary charter – should the government reach out to the other 15% of lenders?
Santander’s Bradley Fordham suggests those 15% of the market could be specialist lenders, such as buy-to-let (which is not covered by the charter).
Nigel Terrington, CEO of Paragon Banking Group (which focuses on the BTL market) says he would happily sign the charter.
Stay connected with us on social media platform for instant update click here to join our Twitter, & Facebook
We are now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@TechiUpdate) and stay updated with the latest Technology headlines.
For all the latest Business News Click Here