The Provencal Rosé Paradox: Why wine you enjoy on holiday doesn’t taste the same back in the UK

With its pale pink colour and delicious flavours of summer berry, the rosé found in Provence has become synonymous with the region.

If you’ve been to the South of France, you may have even liked the wine so much that you decided to buy a few bottles to bring home and enjoy with friends.

But despite tasting incredible in the French summer sun, the wine never tastes quite the same on a cold winter’s night in Britain.

Now, Oxford University’s Professor Charles Spence has explained the phenomenon, which he’s dubbed the Provencal Rosé Paradox.

‘The same wine can taste so different, depending on the situation in which we happen to find ourselves,’ Professor Spence said.

With its pale pink colour and delicious flavours of summer berry, the rosé found in Provence has become synonymous with the region

Professor Spence worked with wine distributors, Berkmann Wine Cellars, to understand why the same food and wine can taste so different under different scenarios.

The team surveyed 2,000 respondents, and found that 62 per cent appreciate the taste of food and drink more when dining out with friends than at home.

However, 58 per cent said that having dinner with someone they don’t like can ruin the taste of a meal for them.

Professor Spence said: ‘There is an intrinsic link between social and emotional cues and the experience of eating food and drinking wine.

‘This plays into the idea of the “social facilitation effect”, a well-known gastrophysics theory in which we tend to enjoy food and drink more when in the presence of people we like.’

It’s not just the people we’re with that can influence taste – location is also important, according to Professor Spence.

‘The flavour and enjoyment of a specific wine can change based on the context and environment,’ he said.

‘Many of us are familiar with the experience of enjoying rosé wine in the South of France.

‘It can taste so wonderful that we end up buying a few bottles to bring back home and share with friends on a cold winter’s night.

‘Only it is very often a disappointment – the wine tastes different, somehow much less enjoyable.

Despite tasting incredible in the French summer sun, the wine never tastes quite the same on a cold winter’s night in Britain (stock image)

‘This is the paradox – how the same wine can taste so different, depending on the situation in which we happen to find ourselves.’

On holiday, we’re usually happy and relaxed, which can boost our appreciation of flavours, according to Professor Spence.

‘The social situations we are in can really influence the way we experience taste – enjoyment which comes from a preferred social interaction will automatically boost our mood, meaning our ability to appreciate flavour is significantly increased,’ he added.

The study comes shortly after researchers claimed that when it comes to white wine, you should avoid varieties that come in clear bottles.

Researchers from the University of Trento found that wines stored in transparent vessels – known as ‘flint glass’ – can react with light to develop nasty aromas, including ‘boiled cabbage’ and ‘wet dog’.

‘Light can dramatically damage the aroma profile and sensorial identity of varietal white wine in less than a week of shelf-life in flint glass bottles,’ the researchers wrote in their study, published in PNAS.